Mossberg: XPS One poses threat to Apple, Gateway
updated 01:10 pm EST, Thu December 27, 2007
Mossberg on Dell XPS One
Dell's recently-launched XPS One computer may pose a serious threat to Apple's iMac, says popular columnist Walt Mossberg. Like the iMac or the Gateway One, the XPS One combines the internals of a computer with an LCD monitor, making for an extremely compact system. Mossberg notes, however, that the XPS comes with features even the iMac does not, such as a TV tuner and a built-in card reader, as well as a wireless mouse and keyboard bundle which Mac users must pay extra for.
The design is also more convenient in some ways, with USB and headphone ports mounted on the side instead of the rear, and a dedicated button for turning off the screen without shutting off the computer. Furthermore, where simplified media playback requires a remote and a new menu (Front Row) on an iMac, XPS users must only interact with a touch panel on the system's right border.
Mossberg is ultimately recommending the iMac though, as he argues for the superiority of Mac OS X Leopard over Windows Vista, primarily because of the included iLife suite and less vulnerability to malware. He also notes that a comparable iMac is at least $100 cheaper, despite having a dedicated graphics card. [via Wall Street Journal]










x
12/27, 01:23pm reply
first off, the iMac runs OSX and Dell runs Windows. So that alone refutes Mossberg's claim.
second, not everyone prefers a wireless keyboard and mouse for the simple reason of having to worry about changing batteries, or facing lesser Mouse performance.
BelugaShark
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined: Aug 2007
Uh...
12/27, 01:38pm reply
Uh, Belugashark, maybe you should read the actual article, or even the third paragraph of this MacNN story. I know, reading can be difficult for some.
"Mossberg is ultimately recommending the iMac though, as he argues for the superiority of Mac OS X Leopard over Windows Vista, primarily because of the included iLife suite and less vulnerability to malware. He also notes that a comparable iMac is at least $100 cheaper, despite having a dedicated graphics card."
Guest
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined: Nov 1999
yup
12/27, 01:44pm reply
"USB and headphone ports mounted on the side instead of the rear" Agreed, this is much better and I still do not understand why apple take so long till they realize the obvious, like putting FW, USB, and Audio jacks in the front?? What is the hold-up
"... a dedicated button for turning off the screen without shutting off the computer." This is actually available on all macs, it's called the power-button. Click it and the computer goes to sleep, shutting off the monitor.
bloggerblog
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined: Aug 2007
RE: uh...
12/27, 01:46pm reply
yeah I know... I was refuting the "pose a serious threat" phrase and not the third paragraph.
BelugaShark
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined: Aug 2007
threat from what?
12/27, 01:51pm reply
A more expensive computer with fewer features, and inferior software. Sounds like another Dell clunker to me.
ClevelandAdv
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined: Jul 2004
Form...
12/27, 02:00pm reply
From an ascetics viewpoint, Apple doesn't want cords and wires sticking out of the side of the iMac. From a practical viewpoint, a single USB port and moving the headphone jack to the side would make sense.
Robb
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined: Feb 2000
I'd really like it if...
12/27, 02:01pm reply
Apple would be kind enough to add a SDHC slot to their entire line of computers. I added one to my MacBook Pro via the Express Card/34 slot and it sure comes in handy for storage.
Constable Odo
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined: Aug 2007
Someone's getting OLD
12/27, 02:07pm reply
and SENILE. Time to sit back and eat marshmellows ol fella. Your days as tech critic has officially been flushed down the toilet by that insulting and totally ridiculous comment. DELL? Get real.
jarod
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined: Apr 2005
read the article, people
12/27, 02:14pm reply
unless you're too cheap or lazy to go read the article at mossberg's website. he's one of the most respected critics for 'real people' tech, and every single pc and gadget maker dreams of favorable reviews from mossberg as it makes a HUGE difference in product success.
just re-read the final paragraph of this article. he acknowledges this is a vast improvement for dell, but ultimately votes for the apple.
i welcome competition for apple in design and functionality, even if it comes from hacks like dell. it benefits all of us.
so spare me the 'your career is over old fella' c***. it's so far from true and shows how closed minded people can be in both the anti-and pro-apple camps.
zl9600
Forum Regular
Joined: Oct 2003
Headphone Jack
12/27, 02:19pm reply
Not so sure it's good to put it on the side or in front. I have external speakers hooked up to mine - would be unsightly to have that always hooked up in front or on the side.
Of course, an audio line out on the back and a separate headphone jack on side/front would be OK...
CreepDogg
Grizzled Veteran
Joined: Jun 2001