Please help us by taking our survey
macnn/electronista

01/05/2008, 1:55am, EST

Saturday, January 5th

HD DVD Group axes CES keynote

The HD DVD Promotional Group tonight reacted to Warner's abandonment of HD DVD for movies by canceling its Consumer Electronics Show keynote on short notice. The organization does not say the keynote is being removed permanently from its scheduled but says it has "postponed" the event without a new date, according to the announcement. Discussions are said to be underway with the group's partners and are widely expected to determine how Toshiba and other HD DVD backers approach the format at the show. A statement from the organization says it remains committed to the "quality and affordability" of the disc format.

Toshiba itself has already reacted to the decision and claims not to understand Warner's decision; HD DVD has had "significant momentum" in the US and other areas and was entirely viable, the electronics maker says. The firm also claims that HD DVD players and equipped PCs have outsold their PC rivals but does not say whether these statistics include Sony's PlayStation 3, which is capable of movie playback. The HD DVD Promotional Group has historically omitted PS3 sales from its statistics and argues that only dedicated movie player and PC drive sales should count towards results.

The statements cloud the expected impact of HD DVD at CES, which was expected to mark a renewal of the conflict between Blu-ray and HD DVD with likely new products unveiled by supporters of each format. Microsoft in particular is rumored to have an Xbox 360 with an HD DVD drive built-in as part of its CES keynote presentation on Sunday and (if true) may be significantly impacted by Warner's decision to offer HD movie discs only in Blu-ray form. The conversion is understood to give Blu-ray a controlling majority of HD movie sales.


Filed under: industry
Other story tags: blu-ray, Toshiba, PS3, Xbox 360, HD DVD, Warner

, , 16comments, del.icio.us, slashdot, digg, buzz
16 comments
Reader Reactions (Please use <i></i> for italic text)

subscribe to comments
for this article




Expand All   Global Settings
Adios HD DVD
0
01/05, 9:34am, EST
Gates can forget releasing any Xbox 360 with a built-in HD DVD drive now. That format will be dead by the end of 2008. Microsoft's attempt to promote HD DVD in order to kill both HD optical formats has failed miserably.
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined Apr 2004
User is offline
Why???
0
01/05, 9:49am, EST
"The HD DVD Promotional Group has historically omitted PS3 sales from its statistics and argues that only dedicated movie player and PC drive sales should count towards results."

So an HD-DVD drive on a PC counts towards their sales numbers while a Blu-Ray drive in a PS3 does not for the sake of comparison?

That just seems silly to me. I purchased a PS3 over the summer as I felt it was the best priced and most attractive (based on the ease of firmware updates) Blu-Ray player. I have a dozen+ Blu-Ray discs and have only recently started to play games on the machine.
Forum Regular
Joined Oct 2001
User is offline
Where is Testudo now?
0
01/05, 11:33am, EST
So, Testudo, why don't you help Mr. Gates in dealing with such a miserable strategy? HD-DVD is DEAD, as soon will be the Windows PC. GO APPLE!
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined Jan 2003
User is offline
testudo
0
01/05, 12:12pm, EST
Testudo was an hd-dvd fanboy?
Dedicated MacNNer
Joined Mar 2002
User is offline
testudo
0
01/05, 3:01pm, EST
Testudo is a M$ fanboy.
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined Sep 2002
User is offline
Are they on Drugs
0
01/05, 4:52pm, EST
"argues that only dedicated movie player and PC drive sales should count towards results."

We bought a PS3 purely because it was a Blue Ray player and the cheapest we could find. We primarily s it for Blue Ray DVD's and yes we now play a few games on it as well.

The next press release we see will be from Microsoft saying that they only count Windows Mobile in their statistics and dont count the Iphone as thats irrelevant.
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined Sep 2001
User is offline
It's not over yet...
0
01/05, 5:32pm, EST
The format war is not over yet. Until the other two studios drop support and HD-DVDs are no longer available will it be over.

I'm not buying either in the meantime.

This is still good news. Die HD-DVD die.
Addicted to MacNN
Joined Oct 2001
User is offline
Alright, that is it!
0
01/05, 6:37pm, EST
As far as formats go, I just want someone to lose so that I the consumer can win. I said a while back that I would just buy a dual format player and win no matter who won. Then I said to myself "thats batsh*t retarded." Why should I buy a product under two licenses and play into this war. I would only be subsidizing my crack dealer. So here is the deal, I am not buying. I am not buying either formats. On top of that, until this is over, I am not buying a DVD that isn't blank because I am not going to rebuild my library. I am renting or using Netflix until I get what I want. One format that plays everything on a player at the 200 price point. I want something to make me phase out of traditional DVD. Blu_ray has more storage capacity right now. So I lean towards them. I author DVDs as well. That 1080p 52 in LCD is staying on the shelf. If you are thinking about that DRM, both have been cracked and have only ever been a deterrent not an actual source of protection. "Keeps the honest people honest." While we are being honest. People aren't honest. They see a dollar on the ground and most people will pocket it more than likely. Piracy is going to happen. So what makes either side say they can win? They are just waiting to say who blinks first because I guarantee that I am not the only person out there that hasn't bought a S-DVD because they are willing to upgrade, but don't want to be stuck with Beta-Max (Thanks Sony, even though it was a superior format).
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined Jan 2008
User is offline
my two cents...
0
01/05, 9:27pm, EST
1 - maybe if we always open comments rubbing Testudo - maybe he/ she/ it might never chime in_

It's a theory_

2 - Apple has the iTMS as a download service_ Both Music and Video_ Many other companies have and are following suit_ Yes granted it is quicker to drive to Best Buy and purchase a physical copy or BlockBuster and rent one_ But with all of this download stuff getting easier and quicker and products like Solid State Hard Drives gaining capacity and stability to rival that of Magnetic Platter Drives...

What is the big damned deal about this whole next gen Disc crap? Is there really going to be a media format to come after Blu-Ray/ HD DVD? It seems like who ever initiated the CD/ DVD industry is trying to prolong their dying market_ When it is so cheap to buy an external Drive with 20 times the storage capacity on average_ Or more as they break the Terabyte mark_
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined Oct 2002
User is offline
Re: my two cents...
0
01/05, 10:41pm, EST
Good point. By the time the format war is over and whoever the winner is going to be, it's too late. Movie downloads become mature.... just like CD is slowly phasing out, video stores are closing left and right.
Fresh-Faced Recruit
Joined Nov 2006
User is offline
additional comments:..1..2..Next
Your Comments

In order to post comments: If you are a registered member, please login with your MacNN Forums username and password otherwise please uncheck the checkbox below.


Registered Member?
macnn forums login:

macnn forums password:

Not a member of the MacNN forums? Register now for free.

AT&T Cell Phones: Get your next AT&T phone at 1800mobiles.com

PowerBookMedic will fix any Apple laptop or iPod: We offer Parts, Hard Drives, Superdrives, Ram Upgrades & Repairs all backed up w/ our 1YR Warranty!

Check Out the VIERA from Panasonic!: Enter a New Visual Era with Panasonic VIERA HDTVs. An Enhanced Experience.

Ad: Browse a huge selection now. Find exactly what you want today.

Hugh Downs Reports: Little known heart attack symptom many people tragically ignore.

The Made-for-TV Election - Martin Sheen: Watch how TV News uses Show-Biz to Distract You from Being Informed.

Buy from The Apple Store, iTunes.com, Amazon.com, TechDepot, OfficeDepot, Computers4Sure, or donate.