T-Mobile trumps AT&T in cellphone customer help rankings

updated 12:05 pm EDT, Thu July 29, 2010

T-Mobile holds on to top spot in quality of care


T-Mobile has beaten AT&T to hold on to its top spot in the quality of its help for customers, JD Power found today. The company had the highest score for its service at 777 points and was the only one of the top four carriers to get a five-star mark from subscribers. It thrived primarily on the level of over-the-phone support.

AT&T scored only slightly lower, at 757, but was rated just three stars by its users. The iPhone provider fared well helping customers at retail but struggled to do the same over the phone. Scores for Verizon and Sprint weren't immediately available, but Verizon's network reputation wasn't enough to avoid a lower score and a three-star rating, while Sprint's attempts to turn around its public image weren't helped as it has a two-star rating.

The ratings are potentially important to holding on to customers as many do act on very high or low rankings. A customer loyal enough to refuse to switch typically scores 827 points, but someone determined to change carriers often rates the current carrier's support at 602.

AT&T's problems with 3G oversaturation in key areas has often been considered a major liability to its help, but the JD Power rankings suggest the network isn't as strong a factor as once thought. A separate study recently showed that iPhone owners were more loyal to AT&T even when the service as a whole had slightly below-average satisfaction.


By Electronista Staff

toggle

Previous Comments

  1. shellyismental

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Jul 2010

    0

    Anything is better than AT&T

    Well of course iPhone customers are more loyal to AT&T because right now that's the only provider. AT&T services are horrible and that's the main reason I will not get an iPhone. At least not until Apple decides to expand the providers like they've done in Europe.


  1. lkrupp

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: May 2001

    0

    Anecdotal = Useless

    @shellyismental

    This professional survey proves your statement is poppycock. You have succumbed to the FUD spread by iPhone/at&t detractors. In fact, every time an issue of any kind on any network appears it is blown completely out of proportion by the blogs and their anonymous posters, many of whom have agendas. And every time an issue becomes the internet whipping boy of the FUDsters a professional survey, a professional expert, a rational examination proves just the opposite. Remember Steve Jobs' claim about it taking up to three years to get a cell tower approved in San Francisco? Turned out to be true didn't it.

    You prove the point. You don't own an iPhone. You don't have an at&t account. You just started to believe what you read on the internet and are parroting the FUD. In fact, you just recently joined this forum so you are most likely a troll trying to get your licks in.


  1. lkrupp

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: May 2001

    +1

    Trust...

    I'll trust the opinion of professionals over any anonymous posters in some backwater user forum.


  1. andrewbw

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Jan 2001

    0

    Hilarious!

    Speaking of unhinged, anonymous sociopaths on message boards: lkrupp. You need medicine. Or a hobby. Or something. But I will say this, you are right at home with all the other foamy-mouthed malcontents on the linkbait king of the internet, MacNN.


  1. testudo

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Aug 2001

    +2

    Re: Anecdotal = useless

    This professional survey proves your statement is poppycock.

    Actually, it proves nothing of the kind. This survey is about customer service satisfaction, as in "I had a problem, how satisfied was I with the resolution process". His statement was all about ATT's actual ATT service. (And he was actually referencing the loyalty article, which he correctly points out that the customer is more likely to be loyal to ATT if they can't take their iPhone - which is what they care about - to another carrier).

    You have succumbed to the FUD spread by iPhone/at&t detractors.

    Oh, as opposed to the FUD spread by the anti-Android crowd talking up stupidity like "Oh, it's more insecure!" and "There's 20,000 malware apps available!" and other nonsense and half-truths.

    And I'm still waiting for one person to explain why the antenna issue was all FUD when no previous version of the iPhone, nor any other phone, caused so many issues to actually raise awareness? Shouldn't every previous version of the iPhone brought out the FUD-monsters with these issues?

    In fact, every time an issue of any kind on any network appears it is blown completely out of proportion by the blogs and their anonymous posters, many of whom have agendas.

    That's right. All issues with Apple products are minor. And affect barely anyone. It's just all those people out there with AGENDAS that are causing problems.

    And don't you also have an agenda by basically saying anyone complaining about an Apple product is out to get Apple?


  1. testudo

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Aug 2001

    +2

    More

    And every time an issue becomes the internet whipping boy of the FUDsters a professional survey, a professional expert, a rational examination proves just the opposite.

    Actually, no one has proved the opposite in the antenna issue. In fact, Apple admits they have an issue. They haven't fixed it (unless you're one of those FUDsters who calls 'get a case' a 'fix'). All they have done is say "Well, those other phones have a problem too!"

    And if anyone is spreading FUD with that issue, it is Apple. The iPhone is much more susceptible to a problem with the antenna because touching it in the right place detunes it. You don't have detuning issues with any of the other phones. Those are all based on blocking signals with your hand.

    So, with the iPhone 4, you could have it sit on your desk, take your finger, and touch the magic spot and have reception die. You cannot do that with any other phone.

    Remember Steve Jobs' claim about it taking up to three years to get a cell tower approved in San Francisco? Turned out to be true didn't it.

    What does that have to do with anything? And what makes it true? That it took ATT three years to finally improve service? That doesn't make it true, that just means it took ATT that long to do something useful.

    You prove the point. You don't own an iPhone. You don't have an at&t account. You just started to believe what you read on the internet and are parroting the FUD. In fact, you just recently joined this forum so you are most likely a troll trying to get your licks in.

    Or, perhaps, he did use ATT at one time and refuses to go back because of the hellscape they foisted upon him. Just like you will find people who will never go back to Verizon or Sprint or T-Mobile.

    As to owning an iPhone, what does that have to do with it? If you've used any phone on ATT and had horrendous service, dropped calls, etc, you're going to get it with an iPhone too. The iPhone might be magical, but it doesn't fix ATT's issues. It just glosses over them by going "What? The call dropped? That's OK, because look at all the other great things you can do with this phone!"


Login Here

Not a member of the MacNN forums? Register now for free.

 
close
Photo
toggle

Network Headlines

toggle

Most Popular

10 Most Read

Recent Reviews

Logitech Cube

The world of mice could often be described charitably as stagnant: it's an endless sea of ergonomic shapes that assume you're sitting ...

NewerTech and Targus USB Hubs For Gifts

A useful holiday present to resolve an ongoing frustration is a multi-port hub. Whether as a stocking stuffer, Chanukah present, or an ...

X-Rite ColorMunki Photo

Color calibration is the art of tweaking your monitor so that the colors represented on screen better match real life and your printer ...

toggle

Most Commented

10 Most Discussed

 
toggle

Popular News