Printed from http://www.electronista.com

Why Microsoft’s PC versus Mac page falls apart

updated 09:10 pm EDT, Tue August 17, 2010

Editorial: MS comparison page is self-destructive

(Editorial) I'm all for companies taking aim at others. In fact, I think it's a smart move in many cases, since it gives firms the ability to highlight, on their own turf, exactly why they believe their products are better than any others. But Microsoft's decision to build a "PC versus Mac" page on its Windows 7 site is a huge mistake, even if you're a Windows supporter.

One of the most glaring issues with the page is Microsoft's contention that "Macs might spoil your fun." According to Microsoft, "Macs can't connect to an Xbox 360." That's very true out of the box, but only if you don't use third-party apps like Connect 360. But even then, why should they? I realize that there are some gamers that really like having the ability to link their PCs with their Xbox 360s, but this isn't the most popular option and won't clinch the deal.

I'm also a little confused by Microsoft's contention that "the mouse works differently" on a Mac. I use a Logitech mouse designed for a Windows PC. When I was using the same mouse on a Mac, I was able to use it just as I do now -- the left click allowed me to choose different windows and items, and the right click brought up dialog boxes. Sorry, but I just don't get it. Anyone who buys a regular mouse to go with a Mac will have the same experience, and getting a right click on a Magic Mouse is as simple as turning it on in System Preferences. If you care about it, you'll find it.

Microsoft also says that "many PCs running Windows 7 support touch." That, the company says, is very much unlike Macs. Here the company is once again being selective, since it's cherry picking what it defines as support. Anyone who's used a Mac with a Wacom Cintiq display will tell you they've had touch for years. And while it's referring to touchscreens, Microsoft must have about multi-touch capabilities that have been baked in since 2008 on most MacBook trackpads or the new Magic Trackpad Apple recently announced.

Don't even get started on its claims about Office compatibility. That Microsoft conveniently omits its own Office for Mac suite makes it clear that truth is far from its top priority here.

The list goes on. But, more than the individual items, the Microsoft "PC versus Mac" page stinks of the desire to show a brave face in the hopes of turning consumers off to Macs. Admittedly, Windows 7 is a fine operating system that, as I write this, is working quite well. And some of the items Microsoft lists on the page are valid. But that doesn't mean that the site should exist in the first place.

Microsoft is the world's most successful software company. It has been able to leverage Windows, Office, and any number of other products for its own gain. And it has enjoyed such strong growth in the face of Apple. At this point, with a strong operating system, over 90 percent market share, and little chance of Apple stealing significant chunks of the market away, its PC-Mac page makes it looks worse than better. Is it simply trying to rub it in Apple's nose or is it actually worried that Mac OS X will rob some share of the OS market? In either case, it makes Microsoft look bad, especially as it revives the classic FUD (Fear, Uncertainty and Doubt) tactic many had pinned to the company starting from the 1990s.

So, maybe it's time to take the "PC versus Mac" page down from Microsoft's Windows 7 site. It recasts the same, simplistic and outdated arguments Windows supporters have been making for years, and it makes Microsoft look desperate. Good technology stands largely on its own merits.



By Electronista Staff
toggle

Comments

  1. qazwart

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Apr 2001

    +31

    comment title

    You missed the two biggest issues:

    1). They're too late. The big thing isn't the desktop, but the tablet, I mean "slate" computer. That's why we haven't see Apple's Mac vs. PC ads for quite a while. Apple has moved on to a new profit making area while Microsoft is still licking its wounds over the old Apple campaign.

    2). The only people who will see that ad are WIndows users. Apple's campaign was pitched to PC users. Sure, they had the ads on Apple's webpage, but Apple is a hardware company. Besides, they also ran those ads on TV and on the web.

  1. DaJoNel

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Aug 2010

    +23

    comment title

    Microsoft has such control but still has to spread lies about their competition. Honestly, I pity them; they're pathetic.

    Windows 7 is pretty good; I firmly believe that Snow Leopard is better, but Microsoft is taking strides toward better products. With the success of W7 and their vice grip on the industry, this page is ridiculous.

    The question is, does this page somehow end up helping Apple? It could actually turn some people against Microsoft.

  1. facebook_Shane

    Via Facebook

    Joined: Aug 2010

    +5

    Macs run more software than a PC ... read on

    Yes its true , Macs run any software and more than a PC... really ? ... read on.
    Why is this true?
    I can install any OS I want any Linux Windows 7 NT XP you name it
    A PC cant install OS X so when I buy a PC I loose out on all those other options.
    If MS was saying dont go to the shop to buy OS X Buy Windows 7 OS instead it would be different but they are talking of buying a piece of hardware.
    So there comments that a MAc cant connect to an XBox 360 are just stupid.

    I'd simply list all the things a PC cant do cause it cant install OS X ..
    smile

    Comment buried. Show
  1. facebook_Shane

    Via Facebook

    Joined: Aug 2010

    -17

    Macs run more software than a PC ... read on

    Yes its true , Macs run any software and more than a PC... really ? ... read on.
    Why is this true?
    I can install any OS I want any Linux Windows 7 NT XP you name it
    A PC cant install OS X so when I buy a PC I loose out on all those other options.
    If MS was saying dont go to the shop to buy OS X Buy Windows 7 OS instead it would be different but they are talking of buying a piece of hardware.
    So there comments that a MAc cant connect to an XBox 360 are just stupid.

    I'd simply list all the things a PC cant do cause it cant install OS X ..
    smile

  1. SwissMac

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Aug 2006

    +25

    Microsoft's being dishonest - again!

    Why are there Office compatibility issues? Because Microsoft intend there to be? Or because MS are so dumb they can't even have versions of their own software read files made by other versions of the same MS software? Either way, Microsoft is just drawing attention to their insecurity and small mindedness.

    Comment buried. Show
  1. facebook_Shane

    Via Facebook

    Joined: Aug 2010

    -20

    Macs run more software than a PC ... read on

    Yes its true , Macs run any software and more than a PC... really ? ... read on.
    Why is this true?
    I can install any OS I want any Linux Windows 7 NT XP you name it
    A PC cant install OS X so when I buy a PC I loose out on all those other options.
    If MS was saying dont go to the shop to buy OS X Buy Windows 7 OS instead it would be different but they are talking of buying a piece of hardware.
    So there comments that a MAc cant connect to an XBox 360 are just stupid.

    I'd simply list all the things a PC cant do cause it cant install OS X ..
    smile

  1. facebook_Shane

    Via Facebook

    Joined: Aug 2010

    -5

    Macs run more software than a PC ... read on

    sorry for the multiple posts can some one delete the extras please.
    thanks

  1. SockRolid

    Forum Regular

    Joined: Jan 2010

    +35

    Microsoft can't win

    When Apple mentions Microsoft, Apple wins.
    When Microsoft mentions Apple, Microsoft loses.

  1. facebook_Justin

    Via Facebook

    Joined: Aug 2010

    +23

    comment title

    Apple should say "PC's can't show E-Mails, send or receive IM's, edit videos or even show calendars" cause Microsoft REMOVED nearly half of the apps from Windows 7. So, out of the box, your PC is one dull Piece of c***.

  1. JuanGuapo

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Jan 2008

    +4

    Hmmm...

    Microsoft vs. Apple? Apple.
    Microsoft vs. Yahoo? Yahoo.
    ...yet...
    Microsoft vs. Google? Microsoft.

Login Here

Not a member of the MacNN forums? Register now for free.

toggle

Network Headlines

toggle

Most Popular

Sponsor

Recent Reviews

IDrive cloud backup and sync service

There are a lot of cloud services out there, and nearly all of them can be used for backing up key files and folders. A few dedicated ...

Asus Chromebook C300

When Chromebooks hit the market back in 2011, consumers didn't know what to do with them. The low-cost laptops, powered by Google's Ch ...

Plantronics BackBeat Pro Bluetooth headphones

Looking for a pair of headphones that can do everything a user requires is a task that can take some study. Trying to decide on in-ear ...

Sponsor

toggle

Most Commented

 
toggle

Popular News