Apple wins again, speeds up Samsung trial to July 30, 2012

updated 01:40 pm EDT, Fri August 26, 2011

Apple has Samsung suit trial date expedited


Apple continued a string of wins against Samsung in its legal battles by speeding up the trial date for its core lawsuit against Samsung in the US. The Northern District of California court issued an order (below) issued an order setting the trial for July 30, 2012. While half a year later than the February 2012 date Apple had wanted, it would be much earlier than the March 2013 Samsung had suggested by targeting the median date for trial starts.

For the iPhone maker, the more favorable date was part of a rally after Judge Lucy Koh denied attempts to 'streamline' the case by having Samsung's newly included counterclaims broken out. Apple had already been shot down in an attempt to speed up the overall process.

Samsung also just recently won the exit of potentially conflicting lawyers. The Korean company had been alarmed after it learned that some attorneys from Bridges & Mavrakakis representing Apple had recently been involved in supporting Samsung, possibly leading to them having inside knowledge of Samsung's workings that could be used in Apple's case.

The advantage to Apple should come in the scope of the trial as well as the timing. Apple is making a large number of claims and is facing extra claims from Samsung; the mid-2012 date gives Samsung less time to prepare its defense. With 18 other cases active around the world, the schedule raises the likelihood that Apple will have a major US verdict against Samsung before other cases complete and risk handing any wins to Samsung. [via Florian Mueller]

11-08-25 Apple v. Samsung NDCA Scheduling Order


By Electronista Staff

Other Articles

toggle

Previous Comments

    Comment buried. Show
  1. facebook_Robert

    Via Facebook

    Joined: Aug 2011

    -10

    thats no win

    That's not a win, thats just called setting the court date.

    Btw, Apple just lost big time in the EU case - every single patent argument was tossed out by the Court on prior art, except one.

    That one, was not even specific to Android - only to Samsung's own Gallery app - and Samsung will have that replaced in short order.

    Apple wants to move this trial up? They'll move up their loss that much quicker.

    If you don't believe in prior art, here is some pictures for you, thanks to osnews

    Tablet design, HP Compaq TC1100 circa 2005
    http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/a8/TC1100-1.JPG/250px-TC1100-1.JPG

    Square buttoned homescreen
    http://www.mobileindustryreview.com/media/nokia-7710.jpg

    swipe to unlock, neonode n1m circa 2005
    http://www.mobilmania.cz/Files/Obrazky/art18/Neonode_N1/D/02.gif

    Do I have to find a device with one home button?

    Guys - Apple copied every bit of it, and claims to own it, because they do such a good job of putting it together.

    No - because they do such a good job of putting together, they get to be the market leader - thats the reward. You don't get the reward of claiming ownership of other people's work - that's a bridge too far.


    Comment buried. Show
  1. facebook_Robert

    Via Facebook

    Joined: Aug 2011

    -10

    thats no win

    That's not a win, thats just called setting the court date.

    Btw, Apple just lost big time in the EU case - every single patent argument was tossed out by the Court on prior art, except one.

    That one, was not even specific to Android - only to Samsung's own Gallery app - and Samsung will have that replaced in short order.

    Apple wants to move this trial up? They'll move up their loss that much quicker.

    If you don't believe in prior art, here is some pictures for you, thanks to osnews

    Tablet design, HP Compaq TC1100 circa 2005
    http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/a8/TC1100-1.JPG/250px-TC1100-1.JPG

    Square buttoned homescreen
    http://www.mobileindustryreview.com/media/nokia-7710.jpg

    swipe to unlock, neonode n1m circa 2005
    http://www.mobilmania.cz/Files/Obrazky/art18/Neonode_N1/D/02.gif

    Do I have to find a device with one home button?

    Guys - Apple copied every bit of it, and claims to own it, because they do such a good job of putting it together.

    No - because they do such a good job of putting together, they get to be the market leader - thats the reward. You don't get the reward of claiming ownership of other people's work - that's a bridge too far.


  1. facebook_Robert

    Via Facebook

    Joined: Aug 2011

    -8

    thats no win

    That's not a win, thats just called setting the court date.

    Btw, Apple just lost big time in the EU case - every single patent argument was tossed out by the Court on prior art, except one.

    That one, was not even specific to Android - only to Samsung's own Gallery app - and Samsung will have that replaced in short order.

    Apple wants to move this trial up? They'll move up their loss that much quicker.

    If you don't believe in prior art, here is some pictures for you, thanks to osnews

    Tablet design, HP Compaq TC1100 circa 2005
    http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/a8/TC1100-1.JPG/250px-TC1100-1.JPG

    Square buttoned homescreen
    http://www.mobileindustryreview.com/media/nokia-7710.jpg

    swipe to unlock, neonode n1m circa 2005
    http://www.mobilmania.cz/Files/Obrazky/art18/Neonode_N1/D/02.gif

    Do I have to find a device with one home button?

    Guys - Apple copied every bit of it, and claims to own it, because they do such a good job of putting it together.

    No - because they do such a good job of putting together, they get to be the market leader - thats the reward. You don't get the reward of claiming ownership of other people's work - that's a bridge too far.


  1. facebook_Robert

    Via Facebook

    Joined: Aug 2011

    -8

    thats no win

    That's not a win, thats just called setting the court date.

    Btw, Apple just lost big time in the EU case - every single patent argument was tossed out by the Court on prior art, except one.

    That one, was not even specific to Android - only to Samsung's own Gallery app - and Samsung will have that replaced in short order.

    Apple wants to move this trial up? They'll move up their loss that much quicker.

    If you don't believe in prior art, here is some pictures for you, thanks to osnews

    Tablet design, HP Compaq TC1100 circa 2005
    http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/a8/TC1100-1.JPG/250px-TC1100-1.JPG

    Square buttoned homescreen
    http://www.mobileindustryreview.com/media/nokia-7710.jpg

    swipe to unlock, neonode n1m circa 2005
    http://www.mobilmania.cz/Files/Obrazky/art18/Neonode_N1/D/02.gif

    Do I have to find a device with one home button?

    Guys - Apple copied every bit of it, and claims to own it, because they do such a good job of putting it together.

    No - because they do such a good job of putting together, they get to be the market leader - thats the reward. You don't get the reward of claiming ownership of other people's work - that's a bridge too far.


  1. facebook_Robert

    Via Facebook

    Joined: Aug 2011

    -7

    thats no win

    That's not a win, thats just called setting the court date.

    Btw, Apple just lost big time in the EU case - every single patent argument was tossed out by the Court on prior art, except one.

    That one, was not even specific to Android - only to Samsung's own Gallery app - and Samsung will have that replaced in short order.

    Apple wants to move this trial up? They'll move up their loss that much quicker.

    If you don't believe in prior art, here is some pictures for you, thanks to osnews

    Tablet design, HP Compaq TC1100 circa 2005
    http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/a8/TC1100-1.JPG/250px-TC1100-1.JPG

    Square buttoned homescreen
    http://www.mobileindustryreview.com/media/nokia-7710.jpg

    swipe to unlock, neonode n1m circa 2005
    http://www.mobilmania.cz/Files/Obrazky/art18/Neonode_N1/D/02.gif

    Do I have to find a device with one home button?

    Guys - Apple copied every bit of it, and claims to own it, because they do such a good job of putting it together.

    No - because they do such a good job of putting together, they get to be the market leader - thats the reward. You don't get the reward of claiming ownership of other people's work - that's a bridge too far.


  1. facebook_Robert

    Via Facebook

    Joined: Aug 2011

    -7

    thats no win

    That's not a win, thats just called setting the court date.

    Btw, Apple just lost big time in the EU case - every single patent argument was tossed out by the Court on prior art, except one.

    That one, was not even specific to Android - only to Samsung's own Gallery app - and Samsung will have that replaced in short order.

    Apple wants to move this trial up? They'll move up their loss that much quicker.

    If you don't believe in prior art, here is some pictures for you, thanks to osnews

    Tablet design, HP Compaq TC1100 circa 2005
    http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/a8/TC1100-1.JPG/250px-TC1100-1.JPG

    Square buttoned homescreen
    http://www.mobileindustryreview.com/media/nokia-7710.jpg

    swipe to unlock, neonode n1m circa 2005
    http://www.mobilmania.cz/Files/Obrazky/art18/Neonode_N1/D/02.gif

    Do I have to find a device with one home button?

    Guys - Apple copied every bit of it, and claims to own it, because they do such a good job of putting it together.

    No - because they do such a good job of putting together, they get to be the market leader - thats the reward. You don't get the reward of claiming ownership of other people's work - that's a bridge too far.


  1. redcapzero

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Aug 2007

    +4

    RE:THAT'S NO WIN

    Well Robert, KY laced fore finger(s) or your attention span is what, 2.5 seconds?


  1. aussiearn

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Jan 2011

    +1

    Facevook_robert is a troll

    So Samsungs phones are banned from sale all across Europe but they won??? What an idiot! Facevook_Robert is either a real fundamentalist fandroid or is being paid. Regardless MacNN needs to do something about trolls being able to spam the comments with multiple postings of the same post!!! Many uses haveca very low tolerence for this BS...


Login Here

Not a member of the MacNN forums? Register now for free.

 
close
Photo
toggle

Network Headlines

toggle

Most Popular

10 Most Read

Recent Reviews

iHome iW2 AirPlay speaker

iHome generally isn't known as a luxury brand when it comes to audio, but it is prolific -- the company's docks and speakers are every ...

Logitech Ultrathin Keyboard Cover

One of the iPad's main weaknesses has always been productivity. It's not a question of apps; while it has taken a little time for a na ...

Logitech UE Air Speaker

If maybe a little more slowly than Apple would like, AirPlay is becoming a staple of the wireless speaker market for iOS devices. The ...

toggle

Most Commented

10 Most Discussed

 
toggle

Popular News