Printed from http://www.electronista.com

Lodsys reply to Apple uses poor evidence, may defeat case

updated 05:30 pm EDT, Mon August 29, 2011

Lodsys sur-reply to Apple faces poor prospects

Lodsys showed potential strain in its lawsuit after it issued a sur-reply to Apple's own response. Originally submitted earlier in the month but just discovered Monday, the response makes the questionable claim that Apple can't motion because some of the app developers sued challenge the validity of the patents. Similarly, it contends that the license it has with Apple doesn't make it a licensor and makes generic claims towards Apple having not somehow satisfied a "heavy burden."

Apple is supposedly ignoring the claims themselves and the "plain and unambiguous" terms it has with developers, which supposedly puts all liability on them, according to Lodsys. A minor point also tries to center on language and claims that the "common issues of law and fact" Apple brought earlier doesn't automatically let it intervene, although Apple was using this more as supporting evidence than an automatic determination.

The issues with the claims are basic. By definition, any defendant not ceding ground in a patent lawsuit is disputing the validity of a patent. As the owner of the patents, Lodsys would have to be the licensor. While more contentious, Apple might point to app developers using its in-app purchasing API and thus that this portion of their apps would be covered.

An exhaustion of defenses at Lodsys could see Apple granted its motion to step into the case and could pose trouble for Lodsys in the end. Many of the claim charts it used to accuse developers of violating patents mention Apple technology as a root of the complaint and even cite violations that are within only Apple's side of the equation, such as the App Store. If successfully constructed, Apple's opposition could show Lodsys trying to double-dip on licenses and lose its battle.

Lodsys has been keen to keep Apple out of the case from the beginning and initially started its royalty campaign for in-app purchases under the assumption that it might not face a lawsuit at all, by targeting developers that couldn't afford to fight back. It eventually brought in EA, Rovio, and others only after Apple began using the meager finances of the mostly independent targets as justification for its intervention. [via GrokLaw]

Lodsys sur-reply to Apple in lawsuit vs. Combay et. al.



By Electronista Staff
toggle

Comments

  1. climacs

    Junior Member

    Joined: Sep 2001

    +14

    DIAF Lodsys

    and take Arne and wrenchy with you

  1. ntflavio06

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Dec 2007

    +7

    Apple shows them the door

    I hope Apple gets to intervene to finally show a troll the way business is done....the legal way. Everything about the way Lodsys is doing things sounds absolutely fraudulent. Just check out their web site. Their web site gives you a feel of the way they do business....sneaky and underhanded.

  1. BigMac2

    Forum Regular

    Joined: Dec 2000

    +6

    Liability of using OS APIs.

    In my mind not one should be in patent dispute for using API, licences agreement and term of use type of contracts already taking care of those dispute but patent should protect the owner from being copied. Right now the only way of implementing Lodsys patent on iOS is to use Apple's AppStore API. Court should have dismiss the case.

  1. blshaw

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: Feb 2010

    +3

    Not too bright, are they?

    These idiots are so stupid they don't even know proper English grammar and punctuation. Just read some of their press releases on their web site. Best of luck, trolls....

Login Here

Not a member of the MacNN forums? Register now for free.

toggle

Network Headlines

toggle

Most Popular

Sponsor

Recent Reviews

Fugoo Bluetooth speaker

It's rare to find a Bluetooth speaker that can cover a large array of needs. Generally, speakers are wrapped in a desktop-convenient d ...

Epson LW-600P

Label makers are traditionally simple machines that perform a single task which people feel they can either live with or without. In m ...

DXG IronX 5G9V HD action cam

Since the introduction of the GoPro, numerous action cams have come out of the woodwork to tackle the consumer need for camcorders tha ...

Sponsor

toggle

Most Commented

 
toggle

Popular News