Printed from http://www.electronista.com

Motorola versus Apple judge blog post criticizes patent law

updated 08:26 pm EDT, Tue October 2, 2012

Judge Posner seeks governmental review of entire program

Court of Appeals Judge Richard Posner who dismissed the Apple versus Motorola smartphone patent trial posted a blog entry complaining about the rampancy of patent filings. Posner wrote that "I am concerned that both patent and copyright protection, though particularly the former, may be excessive." The best illustration of the need for patent reform is illustrated by the software industry, according to the blog post.

Posner writes that the software industry is "a progressive, dynamic industry rife with invention. But the conditions thatmake patent protection essential in the pharmaceutical industry are absent. Nowadays most software innovation is incremental, created by teams of software engineers at modest cost, and also ephemeral--most software inventions are quickly superseded." Patents for software are "huge patent thickets, creating rich opportunities for trying to hamstring competitors by suing for infringement--and also for infringing, and then challenging the validity of the patent when the
patentee sues you."

Judge Posner goes on to complain about a shortage of patent examiners proficient enough to adequately examine software patents, the limited technical ability of judges and juries, and the near-impossibility of ruling on damages for infringement of a component of a product rather than its whole. A generally chaotic nature of the software industry, with constantly shifting patent alliances and mergers is also viewed as a complication to patent law.

Patent trolls are decried in the blog post as well. The proliferation of lawsuits by non-practicing entities increases the burden on legitimate patent holders by the "increased market prices above efficient levels, causing distortions in the allocation of resources; to engender wasteful patent races--wasteful because of duplication of effort and because unnecessary to induce invention (though the
 races do increase the pace of invention); to increase the cost of searching the records of the Patent and Trademark Office in order to make sure one isn't going to be infinging someone's patent with your invention; to encourage the filing of defensive patents (because of anticipation that someone else will patent a similar product and accuse you of infringement)."

An interview with Reuters in July was the first voicing of his opinion on the patent wars, arguing that the smartphone industry is suffering from a "proliferation of patents," and that software patents may not be necessary, since writing a program requires much less investment than what a pharmaceutical company, for instance, might put into developing a new drug. "It's not clear that we really need patents in most industries," he says.

The judge's views may have affected the Apple v. Motorola case and others. Many in the industry have complained, though, that the smartphone industry is suffering under a sea of lawsuits, many of them initiated by Apple, or filed in response. Aside from Motorola, Apple's main targets have been Samsung and HTC.

 Posner supports the view that smartphone makers are using patent suits as a competitive weapon.

He points out that paying a legal team is a "small expense" for corporations like Apple, which had $110 billion in cash and securities alone at the end of the March quarter. "It's a constant struggle for survival," he comments. "As in any jungle, the animals will use all the means at their disposal."



By Electronista Staff
Post tools:

TAGS :

toggle

Comments

  1. prl99

    Dedicated MacNNer

    Joined: 03-24-09

    "that the smartphone industry is suffering under a sea of lawsuits, many of them initiated by Apple, or filed in response."

    This sentence paints Apple as both the bad guy and the defendant. There is a need for patent reform but also the definite need for software patents to keep companies like Microsoft and Google from stealing software designs created by other companies, especially Apple. Microsoft did it years ago and Google is simply following Microsoft's lead. Everyone blames Apple for trying to protect it's non-FRAND patents. These are what makes an Apple product a good product, which is why the others want to use them for free. If Posner doesn't like the system or doesn't understand how to deal with it, then retire and do something else. Having someone try a case who is absolutely against the patent system is plain wrong.

  1. fractaledge

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: 03-07-10

    Originally Posted by NewsPosterView Post


    ... a sea of lawsuits, many of them initiated by Apple, or filed in response. Aside from Motorola, Apple's main targets have been Samsung and HTC....



    This bit of propaganda that has been repeated so many times that few question it. Of course it's crApple, they are evil, right?

    Here is an infographic from two years ago:

    http://teakdoor.com/computer-news/93373-whos-suing-who-in-mobile-world.html

    and another one:

    http://blumenthals.com/blog/2010/10/06/infographic-who-is-suing-whom-in-mobile

    You can see the lawsuits are initiated mainly by established players in the mobile world as a response to the rapid growth of a Apple, a newcomer to the business. Apple only started suing when some of the established players (and some new ones) figured out its faster and more effective to just copy Apple than try to slow them down using lawsuits.

Login Here

Not a member of the MacNN forums? Register now for free.

toggle

Network Headlines

toggle

Most Popular

Sponsor

Recent Reviews

Epson PowerLite Home Cinema 2030 projector

With high-definition televisions now the standard, 4K televisions becoming the next big thing, and plasma TVs going the way of the din ...

Life n Soul 8 Driver Bluetooth headphones

When it comes to music on the go, consumers generally have some options to consider when looking for the best experience. While Blueto ...

Tesoro Tizona G2N Elite gaming keyboard

The market for gaming keyboards is getting crowded, starting off with some fairly simple keyboards and diverging into the land of modu ...

Sponsor

toggle

Most Commented

 
toggle

Popular News