Printed from http://www.electronista.com

Opinion: iPad Air + Logitech Folio + Office for iPad = Productivity?

updated 05:48 am EDT, Wed July 30, 2014

iPad Air is a more capable productivity tool than some might expect

The question of how much productivity you can get done on the Apple iPad is one that has persisted since its introduction. Even if the question is not an easy one to answer, it seems almost irrelevant to even ask when one looks at how massively successful the iPad has been since its introduction. The question also depends on what one defines as being 'productivity,' when it has been clear for some time that plenty of people can and do use iPads for getting work done, particularly in creative endeavors. The recently announced partnership between Apple and IBM in enterprise, coupled with the arrival of Microsoft Office for iPad suggests that the iPad's capability in the workplace will be properly tested given that IBM also becomes an official Apple reseller and will help to shift many more units into the workplace.

As with the Apple iPhone, it did not take long to see a third-party accessory industry spring up around the iPad. Chief among these have been keyboard accessories of various kinds, with one of the best exponents of this particular type of accessory being Logitech. The Logitech Ultrathin Keyboard Folio for iPad Air is one of the company's most recent offerings and is the latest refinement of the its keyboard solutions for iPad. It weighs 0.9-pounds (425g) and is 0.79-inches (20.1mm) thick. It's attractive exterior comes in leather (black, blue, red/orange) or Tech Fabric (black, red/orange) and provides rugged protection for your iPad Air as well as its in-built Bluetooth keyboard.



Importantly from a useability perspective, it is good for up to 3 months on a charge. It also features full-size keys as well as special iPad short-cut keys for cut & paste; one important thing to note is that although it features full-size keys, it is not a full-size keyboard which means that it is both narrower than a full-size keyboard, while it also includes some quirky Logitech choices for the left Shift key size, in particular, while overall key positioning does not match what most people are used to. Nonetheless, it remains a good overall choice for investigating the iPad's productivity potential while running Office. As good as Apple's software keyboard is, it takes up half the screen when typing in a Word document. Connecting any type of Bluetooth keyboard instantly frees up the whole display to whatever it is that you are working on.



I've previously Logitech's and other similar keyboard/covers in the past to see if I could get away with using the iPad for Office-style productivity in the past using Apple's own Pages, Keynote and Numbers. However, I never really found it to be a completely satisfactory experience, though others may beg to differ. This was for at least two reasons; firstly any Bluetooth keyboard that is only as wide as a 9.7-inch iPad is always going to feel slightly cramped; secondly, as good as Pages, Keynote and Numbers are, the issue of full document compatibility between Microsoft Office documents is never completely guaranteed. Having access to a native version Office on the iPad addresses the second of these two concerns to at least some degree.



The sheer convenience and portability of the tablet form factor makes the proposition of a tablet/notebook hybrid attractive, which is perhaps why these types of accessories for the iPad continue to thrive. The device that comes closest to making the hybrid dream a reality is the Microsoft Surface, which I have spent some time dabbling with over the past 12-18 months. However, as we know, the Surface has never really taken off, with my theory being that it represents neither the best tablet that you can buy nor the best notebook that you can buy. To date, Apple believes that because of the difficulties of making the perfect hybrid mashup of tablet and notebook, it is perhaps best that the two devices remain distinct. This could also help to explain why Apple itself has not released a keyboard folio for the iPad as the user experience is not equivalent to a full notebook experience.



So where does that leave the experience of using combining the Logitech Keyboard Folio for iPad Air with Microsoft's Office for iPad? As a first up attempt at a touch-first version of Office for any platform, Microsoft has made a very solid entry with Office for iPad. At this stage, the suite includes Word, PowerPoint, Excel and OneNote which are underpinned by Microsoft's OneDrive cloud platform. The advantage of this is that you can now get work done on your iPad and pick up with where you left off at work and vice versa as long as you have an Internet connection. However, you can also download and work on documents natively on the iPad as well, or merge documents at a later time. Office for iPad plays nicely with Office for Mac and Office for Windows, and while each app is a cut-down version of its desktop equivalent, each goes a long way to making the iPad a much better proposition for Office-style productivity than ever.



However, as with my previous experience with Logitech's iPad keyboard folios, as beautifully designed as the latest models are, they are still a substantial compromise in terms of comfort over a full-size keyboard. The Surface is a better proposition in this regard as productivity tablet, even if people still have wider issues and concerns with the Windows 8/8.1 user interface. The Surface TypeCovers 1,2, and 3 are all more comfortable to type on than the Logitech keyboard thanks largely to the wider footprint of the Surface. The iPad, however, offers a brilliant overall tablet and app experience that the Surface can't match and has gained widespread acceptance in enterprise with 98 percent of the companies listed in the Fortune 500 adopting it for use in the workplace. The Apple-IBM deal only serves to reinforce this dominant position.



A better proposition for getting Office-style productivity done on the iPad Air could be to pair it with the Apple Wireless Keyboard and the Incase Origami Workstation, a combination that helps to overcome the issue of a cramped typing experience; although it does not offer the level of integration offered by the Logitech Keyboard Folio. While my intention in this piece was not to make an emphasis of the comparisons between the iPad Air and any of the Surface models, one other distinct advantage that the Surface line offers over the iPad from a tablet Office-style productivity perspective is the split screen view that arrived in the 8.1 update. It is often the case that Office-style productivity demands at least two windows with documents presented side-by-side. However, developers have found code in iOS 8 due this fall that suggests that Apple will also add split screen multitasking in the near future.



Of course, not all tablet apps that help with productivity in the workplace (office-based or in the field) require heavy data entry. There are dozens upon dozens of apps that help people get things done where the built-in iPad software keyboard, or touch input generally, coupled with the mobility benefits of the iPad that make it an ideal choice. The iPad Air is a highly versatile device that continues to confound its detractors who once panned it as being 'just a bigger version of the iPhone.' As Apple and others have repeatedly demonstrated, the larger canvas offered by the iPad means that even though it is running a mobile operating system, it is has found a purpose in many different aspects of people's lives, not least of which is helping people to get more things done with it than some thought likely.

So does iPad Air + Logtitech Keyboard Folio (or equivalent) + Office for iPad = Productivity? Yes, but only up to a certain point. Which is where iOS 8 + OS X Yosemite (Continuity/Handoff) + Mac rounds out the full productivity equation. Who else is starting to see the massive strategic potential in Apple's deal with IBM in driving both iPad and Mac sales?

By Sanjiv Sathiah



By Electronista Staff
Post tools:

TAGS :

toggle

Comments

  1. jpellino

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: 10-29-99

    $799 for an iPad Air 128GB plus $100 for the keypad = $899 @ 2.43lb? Why not just live with the extra .4 lb and get am $899 MBA 11" if you're going for productivity? I love my iPad, but when things get down to the wire, it's my MacBook for hitting deadlines and the last 20% of complicated stuff that the Playskool app suites just aren't up to.

  1. Sabon

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: 03-07-05

    IBM once upon a time had a "Butterfly" keyboard that raised up when you opened up their smaller laptops and then expanded to a full keyboard. That was on their ThinkPads and I was a huge fan. Too bad they didn't run OS X but they did run OS/2 which I loved, loved, loved as an OS.

    As for iPads and office work. I'm a Systems Analyst where I work and when Word or Excel files get corrupt I use Pages and Numbers on my iPad or my Mac to uncorrupt the files, send them back to myself and then send back to the users. They are stunned that I use an iPad to get their documents back for them.

    I create a lot of Tech Documents using my iPad 3 with an Apple Bluetooth wireless keyboard. I have one of the Logitech keyboards made for them but they just aren't the same for me. I use it once in awhile but only for things where I'm out an about and I've got something bigger than I want to use the on-screen keyboard for but smaller than what I want to pull out the Apple Bluetooth keyboard for.

    Note that my Tech Documents have lots of graphics (for those that need the visuals) and quite a few of the bigger ones run over 200 pages (no pun intended). I have zero problems with those sizes of documents. I just have to make sure I have my secured wifi when I email it back to myself and pull it out of (ugh!!!) Outlook and put it back on our server or email it to the group that needs that document.

    I also use Numbers to create and edit spreadsheets.

    You noted that you "can't be sure" that the documents are going to be exactly the same. What I would say to that is that even Word and Excel of different versions "can't be sure" of the documents being exactly the same. So I tell people that say that to get over their snobbery of non MS apps and smell reality that between Word and Excel versions we have always had as many issues as we do with Pages or Numbers.

    I also have friends that use iPads and 256 secure VPN to remote into their work Windows and Mac desktops to write and compile programs from pretty much anywhere.

    No computer, no software, no *anything* works for *everyone*. That's about piece of ********** that people keep trying to peddle. It's all just FUD and I ask the people that don't know me at work if they have problems with the documents I send them. The answer is no. I then tell them I use my iPad more than my Mac desktop more than my Windows desktop for creating and editing my documents and spreadsheets and they are stunned.

    Can it work? Yes. All that is needed is the ******** snobbery of people that bought into the MS distorted reality that is as big or bigger than Apples.

Login Here

Not a member of the MacNN forums? Register now for free.

toggle

Network Headlines

toggle

Most Popular

Sponsor

Recent Reviews

Dell AD211 Bluetooth speaker

For all of the high-priced, over-engineered Bluetooth speakers in the electronics market, there is still room for mass-market solution ...

VisionTek 128GB USB Pocket SSD

USB flash drives dealt the death blow to both the floppy and Zip drives. While still faster than either of the old removable media, sp ...

Kodak PixPro SL10 Smart Lens Camera

Smartphone imagery still widely varies. Large Megapixel counts don't make for a good image, and the optics in some devices are lacking ...

Sponsor

toggle

Most Commented

 
toggle

Popular News