Printed from http://www.electronista.com

Judge Koh blocks Apple attempt to recover attorney fees from Samsung

updated 11:40 pm EDT, Wed August 20, 2014

Releases $2.6M Apple bond covering never-enacted Galaxy Tab 10.1 sales ban

On Wednesday, US Federal District Court Judge Lucy Koh ruled on two motions in the ongoing leftover matters related to the first Apple vs. Samsung patent trial from 2012. The first ruling denied Apple the opportunity to recover attorney's fees from Samsung related to its guilty verdict on trade dress claims, and the second returned a $2.6 million Apple bond the company had put up to enforce a sales injunction against the Galaxy Tab 10.1, which was found to have copied Apple's iPad technology. No action was ever taken on the ban due to the appeals process, and both companies have since agreed to drop the injunction.

Although Apple won - and won big - in the first trial and subsequent limited damages retrial, its desire for product bans on the infringing Samsung products was never fulfilled and subsequently dissolved due to the fact that the sales injunction was stayed while appeals continued, and the product was eventually withdrawn from sale and replaced with newer models that are claimed to be non-infringing.

Samsung's post-trial defense against the attorneys fees compensation request was that the iPhone's design was "utilitarian" and at least partially based on function, reports AppleInsider. Thus, it argued, it was protected in its original misappropriation of Apple's patents by the Lanham Act, a US statute that requires the infringement be proven to be "exceptional" in order to demand attorney's fees, which left Judge Koh with the decision. In her ruling she found the case was not exceptional because "Samsung raised several reasonable defenses to Apple's trade dress dilution claims, establishing that Samsung 'might have reasonably thought that its proposed usage was not barred by the statute.'"

Apple and Samsung recently agreed to drop all non-US patent disputes, which leaves both companies free to pursue appeals to the first and second Apple-Samsung trials. The judge's rulings on Wednesday are available below.






By Electronista Staff
toggle

Comments

Login Here

Not a member of the MacNN forums? Register now for free.

toggle

Network Headlines

toggle

Most Popular

Sponsor

Recent Reviews

Dell AD211 Bluetooth speaker

For all of the high-priced, over-engineered Bluetooth speakers in the electronics market, there is still room for mass-market solution ...

VisionTek 128GB USB Pocket SSD

USB flash drives dealt the death blow to both the floppy and Zip drives. While still faster than either of the old removable media, sp ...

Kodak PixPro SL10 Smart Lens Camera

Smartphone imagery still widely varies. Large Megapixel counts don't make for a good image, and the optics in some devices are lacking ...

Sponsor

toggle

Most Commented

 
toggle

Popular News