Printed from

Judge rebuffs Samsung attempt to invalidate Apple patents

updated 06:33 pm EDT, Fri August 22, 2014

Ruling could have affected outcome of second Apple-Samsung trial

US Federal District Court Judge Lucy Koh has denied Samsung's post-trial request to invalidate two Apple patents, both of which were used successfully to convict Samsung of copying the iPhone maker's technology yet again in the second federal Apple-Samsung trial, held earlier this year. Samsung had filed the motion in early July, based on a recent Supreme Court decision, Alice vs. CLS Banks, which stated that software ideas that were just abstract representations of real-world concepts (such as turning a doorknob) were not patentable.

The two patents Samsung sought to invalidate through a ruling by Koh based on the Alice decision were the '959 "unified search" patent, and the '721 "slide to unlock" patent, both of were judged to have been copied by Samsung. Apple was awarded some $119 million in the final verdict, far less than the company was expecting given its victory.

Koh ruled that Samsung "had not preserved its original invalidity defense" under the prevailing law, and it was now "too late to raise the issue of abstract subject matter," said former patent analyst Florian Mueller. The "slide to unlock" concept doesn't really have a direct correlation to real-world actions, though it has since become "obvious" thanks to Apple's success with the iPhone and the many similar unlocking iterations that success spawned from competitors.

The US Patent and Trade Office has recently and tentatively invalidated the '721 patent, but the full process is a long one and subject to many appeals before a final judgement on the patent's fate is rendered. The USPTO has been known to reverse itself -- sometimes more than once -- in the course of re-examinations of patents.

14-07-03 Samsung's Proposed Supplemental Brief Re. Alice Opinion

By Electronista Staff
Post tools:




  1. Twisted

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: 02-01-08

    "The "slide to unlock" concept doesn't really have a direct correlation to real-world actions"

    Poppycock. Door slide bolts and chain guards, both of which use a slide motion to lock and unlock, predate Apple's abstraction by more than a century. Unknown to people born after 1990 nonobvious to everyone else.

  1. The Vicar

    Junior Member

    Joined: 07-01-09


    A. You don't unlock slide bolts by running your finger along them, or even gesturing in that way (usually they either screw in or are pushed/pulled by a rotating gear) so there's a much more significant difference there than there is between, say, any two patented designs for lightbulbs.

    B. Beyond that, IIRC implementing a metaphor on a computer as a UI mechanism is considered sufficiently different from the real thing to be patentable independently of the real item.

  1. Twisted

    Fresh-Faced Recruit

    Joined: 02-01-08

    @The Vicar. A) You don't seem to know what a slide bolt is; a more advanced version of the cane bolt, which dates to the Middle Ages. No screws, no gears, just slide back and forth. Hence the term, "slide bolt."And chain guards certainly operate by sliding.

    E. g., homedepot dot com/p/Prime-Line-Satin-Nickel-Slide-Bolt-and-Keeper-U-10306/100146947

    homedepot dot com/p/Prime-Line-Satin-Nickel-Chain-Door-Guard-U-10304/100205287

    B) Alice vs. CLS Banks says the opposite, per paragraph 1 above.

Login Here

Not a member of the MacNN forums? Register now for free.


Network Headlines


Most Popular


Recent Reviews

Seagate Wireless

It seems like no matter how much internal storage is included today's mobile devices, we, as users, will always find a way to fill the ...

Lenovo Yoga Tablet 2 (Android, 10.1-inch)

Lenovo is building a bigger name for itself year after year, including its devices expanding beyond desktop computers. The company's l ...

Brother HL-L8250CDN Color Laser Printer

When it comes to selecting a printer, the process is not exactly something most people put a lot of thought into. Printers are often t ...



Most Commented


Popular News